Message No : 4Sr.No : 484/724
Question By : abcde xyz

The story of Mr.A And his wife ( Mrs.A) with his own younger brother Mr.S.

Mr. A working with MNC Company as a sales manager belonging from middle class family he is living with mom , dad & one younger sister one elder brother and younger brother.

Mrs.A was belonging from middle class family before marriage she was non muslim (Hindu),

Mr.A and Mrs.A know each other from 1996 they got affair after complete the education they got married in the year of 2005. They live happy with family members and they got one baby of 2.6 months (female).

Mr A was coming late around 1 Am approx due to reason of charity work becoz may allah will agree with him. He was a very humble man soft hearted person.

Today morning Mr.A has seen his wife and his own younger brother there are having sex at that time he (Mr.A) was sleeping. He got the doubt on his wife and his younger brother relation but he don¡¯t get clue to stop.

¡°She accepts the entire allegation and she was told at that time when Mr.A catches them. Mr.S was force to do but they had done how to deal with and what to do for maafii is there any wayout in islam forgiveness any type e.g Sucide or any thing else or sala¡±

1) Mr.A asking question still she is in my nikah or hampared the nikah? If yes than how to save nikah?
2) Is there any provision in Islam forgiveness
3) What to to with his wife devoce or give a chance?
4) MAAFII KAISE MILLAGA for his wife
5) MAAFII KAISE MILLAGA for his younger brother
6) Mr.A has no right take discussion on the spot he is taking fatwa from you people, please show in the light of islam
Notes: if Mr.A devoce to his wife or any other way out, he has one bab


Reply By : Mohammad Asad Qasmi
Designation : Mufti, ODI, MMERC, Mumbai 

In the name of Allah the most Gracious the most Merciful

The answer to your question is as follows:

One who has committed Zina with his brother¡¯s wife is to be punished according to the local court¡¯s verdict. This happening doesn¡¯t have any effect on Nikah, i.e. there is no need to renew this Nikah. It is up to the husband if he keeps her or divorce her; he has both options and he will not be sinful. Mrs. A and Mr. S must repent to Allah sincerely, pray Salah for forgiveness and give something in charity. While doing so, Mr. A must separate his younger brother from his family for ever. (And Allah knows be

To view complete list of questions posted on the topic Click Here

To post your Question Click Here.

Eastern Cresent
Current Issue October 2012
Click here to join markazulmaarif E-Groups on Yahoo!